Active Analysis

High-stakes matters

Merit Score

Rodriguez v. Mount Sinai — Auto-qualified

Contradictions

Flagged in deposition testimony

Estimated Value

$4.2M

Trial value (NY — uncapped)

🧠 Strategic Analysis: Rodriguez v. Mount Sinai

Priority High

Evidentiary Weakness: 14-Hour Antibiotic Gap

The AI identifies a critical failure in the sepsis protocol. While the defendant testifies to immediate treatment, the MAR shows a 14-hour delay. This is a primary liability pivot.

Impeachment Opportunity: ER Attending Testimony

Witness Alan Miller (Page 34) claims "immediate administration." This is directly refuted by Nursing Log P8. Suggest trapping witness on protocol adherence before introducing exhibit.

Jurisdictional Alert: New York State Caps

Based on current NY case law (22 NYCRR Part 1200), the vicarious liability of the hospital is strengthened by the triage qSOFA score of 2. Settlement value should be adjusted upward.

🤖 AI-Generated Cross-Examination

Q1. "Doctor, would you agree that a 14-hour delay in antibiotics for a qSOFA-2 patient constitutes a breach of the standard of care?"

Q2. "You testified earlier that you 'personally confirmed' the start of IV antibiotics at 19:45, correct?"

Q3. "Then please explain why the hospital's own electronic record shows no such administration until the following morning."

⚖️ Liability Score

VICTORY PROBABILITY: HIGH

Liability Strength96/100

Damage Potential88/100

Venue Favorability74/100

Subpoena Roadmap

Triage IT Audit Logs

Pharmacy Dispensing Records

Internal Quality Review Memos